Shorenstein APARC experts take part in "North Korea 2010" forum
An international forum on North Korea was held in Palo Alto on October 26, 2010, in an effort to educate the public on reunifying the two Koreas. The San Francisco Chapter of the National Unification Advisory Council organized the forum. Approximately 150 audience members heard panelists speak about the economic, social, and political challenges that face South Korea today in its preparation for a peaceful reunification, as well as about their visions for the future of North Korea.
Gi-Wook Shin, the director of the Walter H. Shorenstein Asia-Pacific Research Center (APARC), moderated the presentations and the panel discussion. The panel of four experts included John Everard, 2010-2011 Pantech Fellow at APARC and a former British ambassador to North Korea, speaking about diplomacy and security; Greg Scarlatoiu, director of public affairs and business issues at the Korea Economic Institute, on economic issues; Sang-Hun Choe, 2010-2011 Fellow in Korean Studies at APARC and a reporter at the International Herald Tribune, on factionalism; and Jung Kwan Lee, the South Korean Consul General in San Francisco, on South Korea's policy toward North Korea.
Everad analyzed North Korea's development during the Cold War of a diplomatic technique by which it repeatedly attempted to play one ally off against another in its relationships with the Soviet Union and China. While arguing that North Korea continues to make effective use of this technique against South Korea, the United States, and the European Union, Everad noted that North Korea's current political uncertainty, following the succession, and its ongoing economic concerns will together create a situation in which it may be very difficult for North Korea to maintain political solidarity.
Scarlatoiu, meanwhile, contended that North Korea's is a post-Stalinist, neo-patrimonial economy. Thus, with recent efforts such as the 2002 market reforms and the 2009 currency reform, the North Korean regime has found itself confronted with a major dilemma. According to Scarlatoiu, while economic reforms are necessary to the long-term survival of the regime, they could also lead to the regime's collapse. This predicament, he added, must be considered as the regime undergoes a leadership transition in the succession to Kim Jong-un.
Choe spoke on the process of succession to Kim Jong-un as well, pointing out that while Kim Jong-un is indisputably the heir to the leadership of North Korea, he has yet to prove his competency as North Korea's future leader. In addition, Choe emphasized that difficulties judging North Korea's intentions and anticipating its behavior stem from the outside world's inability to understand the North Korean leadership and the goals that it truly has in mind.
Finally, Lee stressed that the basic objectives of South Korea's policy on North Korea are to promote a common prosperity and to peacefully resolve North Korean nuclear issues. However, he also made it clear that the South Korean government is seeking to keep North Korean nuclear issues distinct from the issue of inter-Korean relations.
SPRIE represented in Governor Schwarzenegger trade mission to Asia
Occupying the greater part of the United States Pacific coastline, California has long shared a relationship with Asia. Today, trade with China, Japan, and Korea accounts for nearly one-fourth of the state's overall $120 billion in exported goods, and an estimated one in seven California jobs is related to trade. In recognition of the crucial importance of this trade for the state's economic vitality, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and 100 business and government leaders embarked on September 9, 2010 for a six-day trade mission to Asia.
Forty representatives from the Bay Area, 40 from southern California, and 20
top government officials traveled with the mission, including leaders from California's
agriculture, green technology (green tech), finance, and healthcare industries.
Although intended to benefit the State of California, the trade mission also
sought to leverage complimentary resources that would help nurture China's
ever-growing innovation economy and to facilitate the continued exchange of
people, technology, and capital. Marguerite Gong Hancock, associate director of
the Stanford Program on Regions of Innovation and Entrepreneurship (SPRIE),
represented Stanford University and SPRIE on the delegation's visits to the
cities of Shanghai and Hangzhou in China. This was the second and final Asia
trade mission led by Governor Schwarzenegger during his tenure.
While in Shanghai and Hanghzou, Hancock engaged with policymakers, university officials,
and private-sector business leaders. She took part in visits to several major
companies, including the Hangzhou headquarters of Alibaba, China's e-commerce
giant, during its "Alibaba Fest," an annual innovation conference. While there,
Hancock and fellow mission members met with the company's president and learned
about recent goods and services innovations, and about its global expansion
strategies. In Shanghai, she visited the home of Zap-Jonway, the recently
merged California electric vehicle manufacturer Zap and Shanghai electric
motorcycle company Jonway. Zap-Jonway's CEO Steve Schneider plans for the
company to develop electric vehicles for commercial fleets, such as taxicabs
and trucks. "It is a really interesting example of California and Shanghai
coming together, bringing technologies from both sides and then positioning
themselves for market growth both in China and here in the United States," says
Hancock.
SPRIE is at the forefront of research about factors that nurture innovation and
entrepreneurship, and has engaged in the last two years in significant research
about green tech. Hancock was frequently asked about how to build policies and
industry strategies that foster the economic growth of green tech and about the
possible implications for China, both in terms of collaboration and
competition, in the shift in Silicon Valley's economy toward green tech.
During the Asia trade mission, Governor
Schwarzenegger also made several important public announcements, including the
news that California is going to formally bid to hold the 2020 World Expo at
Moffett Field in Mountain View, which would be a major opportunity to showcase
the best of the region's innovation and entrepreneurship to the world.
For more details about Governor Schwarzenegger's Asia trade mission, please
visit the State of California's
website.
Kim Jong-un will be like his father: ambitious, aggressive and ruthless
The North Korean leader Kim Jong-il and his youngest son and presumed successor, Kim Jong-un, jointly attended military maneuvers on an unspecified date. This was the first official outing of the 27-year-old youngest son of the "Dear Leader." These maneuvers were held just before the Sunday celebration of the 65th anniversary of the founding of the Workers Party of Korea. David Straub, associate director of the Korean Studies Program at Stanford University, discussed the informal transfer of power that took place last week.
What was learned last week about
the succession to Kim Jong-il in North Korea?
The maneuvers confirmed with near certainty the past few years of speculation
that the third son of Kim Jong-il has been informally designated as his
successor. This process is now public. This is the first time that the name of
Kim Jong-un has been published in North Korea. However, as long as his father
is alive and can govern, he will remain in power. But, clearly, his health is
not good. This official outing of the son seems in preparation for the
possibility that Kim Jong-il may die suddenly. Kim Jong-il suffered a stroke in
2008, after which he disappeared for several months. Upon his return, he had
lost weight and appeared stiff and impaired on his left side.
Was Kim Jong-un touted as the successor?
There were no signs until a few years ago. First, it was Kim Jong-nam, the
eldest son, who was favored. Officially, he fell out of the race when he was
caught entering Japan with a forged passport. At the time, he told Japanese
officials he wanted to take his son to Tokyo Disneyland [the target of an attempted
contract killing by Kim Jong-un in 2008, the eldest now lives happily in Macao,
ed.]. It is then the second son, Kim Jong-chol, who was poised to be the
successor. But in Pyongyang, it was thought that he was not sufficiently
ambitious and aggressive. Then, all eyes turned to Kim Jong-un, who has the
personality of his father: ambitious, aggressive, and ruthless.
The main question then was how Kim Jong-un would be promoted. Most observers were betting on a gradual process. In this sense, it is not really surprising. He was appointed as a four-star general, which is a mostly symbolic distinction. He was also made vice-president of the Central Military Party. This underscores how strong the military is in North Korea. What surprised me most is that the younger sister of Kim Jong-il was also appointed as a four-star general. In line with the predictions of observers, Kim Jong-il has mobilized his immediate family to create a sort of regency capable of supporting his son in the event of his sudden death.
What is known about Kim Jong-un?
He was probably born in 1983 or 1984. However, the regime may try to say he was
born in 1982. In Chinese culture-and also in North Korea-numbers are
significant. Kim Il-sung, his grandfather, was born in 1912. Kim Jong-il was
born in 1942. That would put Kim Jong-un in a kind of celestial lineage. It is
almost certain that he attended school in Switzerland, where he was a quiet
student. He had a false name, Pak-un, and one or two close friends. He also
liked basketball. He then returned to Pyongyang. Some unconfirmed reports say
he studied at a military university. A few years ago, it was said he had been
appointed to the office of the Workers Party and the office of National Defense
Committee, which is the highest organ of power in North Korea.
Who now heads North Korea? What is the
power structure like?
The general view is that Kim Jong-il is the supreme leader-an absolute
dictator-and he has tremendous latitude. He bases his legitimacy on the fact
that he is the son of the founder of the regime. But nobody can run a country
alone. He must therefore take into account various factors. In North Korea in
recent decades, the military has played a growing role and seems to occupy a
dominant place today.
A university professor based in South Korea believes that the regime in Pyongyang has greatly copied Japanese pre-war fascism, even though Korea fought against imperialism. The scheme is based on a totalitarian structure, relying in particular upon the military. Information is very strictly controlled and the population is monitored, as in East Germany. The structure remains very closed, and the leadership is afraid to open up to the outside world and receive investment or foreign aid. Finally, family occupies an important place. North Korea is part of China's cultural sphere, with a strong presence of Confucianism. The notion of the state is close to the family structure model. The king is seen as the head of the family.
Does a period of transition put the
regime in danger? What took place before?
It is inevitable that one day a regime that is so rigid and incapable of
transformation will suffer major changes. However, we cannot say when or what
form this will take. But it is clear that unusual things can happen during a
period of change like this. The last transition was very similar to the current
process. The difference is that Kim Jong-il had been clearly designated as the
successor by his father and he had decades to gradually gain experience and
consolidate his power within the system. Kim Jong-il managed most affairs of
state since 1980, when the last Workers Party meeting was held. He was the de facto leader for 14 years. When his
father died in 1994, however, he took three years to formally become established
as the leader. The difference today is that Kim Jong-il suffered a stroke in
2008. Some people in North Korea are afraid that his son had not had enough
time to prepare for power. Kim Jong-un must particularly ensure that the
military is loyal to him. That is why he was made a general.
What legacy does he leave his son Kim
Jong-un?
Although North Korea has said for decades that it follows the principles of juche or self-sufficiency, it largely
sustained itself during the Cold War by trade with the USSR and its satellite
states, and China. It received much help. Now that the USSR has collapsed and
China has turned to a market economy, the economic situation in North Korea has
become untenable. The country suffered a terrible famine in the mid-1990s.
Nobody knows for sure how many people died, but it was certainly several
hundred thousand. Some say that there were more than one million deaths, out of
a total population of 22-23 million people. The government then had to loosen
its grip on the system. This has helped the country recover. Today, access to
basic resources is much better in North Korea than it was fifteen years ago.
The country was also helped by foreign aid from Japan, South Korea, the United States, and China. Now, because of the crisis over its nuclear program, the only foreign aid that comes into Pyongyang is from China. The North Korean regime faces a dilemma: its only resource is its workers. It fears opening up to accept foreign capital and technology, which would expose the people to outside reports that fundamentally contradict the regime's decades-old claims. That is why the few commercial contacts are with ideologically similar countries, like Syria or Iran. As for the industrial project in Kaesong near the border between North and South, it is very closely monitored by the authorities.
What is the situation at the diplomatic level?
North Korea has no close allies in the world. It cooperates with Cuba, Syria, or Iran, but these countries are isolated. Their relationship is either rhetorical or in connection with the nuclear program. As for its neighbors, North Korea does not like them. The South is seen as an existential threat; it is another Korean state, comprising two-thirds of the Korean nation, and has been a phenomenal success. The situation is different with China. Officially, both countries are driven by an eternal friendship, but this is based primarily on strategic considerations. Nevertheless, China provides a lifeline to North Korea.
Finally, I think in the last two decades, Pyongyang has toyed with the idea of a strategic alliance with the United States to counterbalance Chinese influence. But for domestic political reasons and because of the situation of human rights in North Korea, the Americans have never pushed this idea further. The North Koreans have realized that this strategic relationship was probably a dream.
The fundamental problem behind all of this is due to an accident of history. After the liberation of the peninsula from Japanese occupation in 1945, the division between the Soviets and Americans-for practical reasons-was not intended to be permanent. Today, there are two states, each of which thinks that it best represents the Korean nation and that it should be in charge of the affairs of the peninsula in its entirety. It is a zero-sum game. All issues about the current succession flow from this.
Flowing Back to the Future: The Cheonggye Stream Restoration
The speaker says that restoration of Cheonggye stream in downtown Seoul is arguably the most prestigious and controversial construction project in Korea today. Since its reopening in 2005 after having been buried for half a century, the stream site has become an important leisure place for the urban populace. It has also become an icon of greener Seoul in it’s quest for a global city status. In the meantime, the stream project also actively mobilized the discourses of national identity restoration, heritage and "people." This talk is about the ideology and the representation of Cheonggye stream. It will focus on how the stream project seeks to revive a sense of the shared past as a galvanizing force in what is after all divisive transformations in the new urban economy of contemporary Korea. The speaker aims to show how the stream restoration represents an important shift in the mode of governing the urban population.
Dr. Hong Kal is Associate Professor of Art History at the department of Visual Arts, York University. Her research explores the politics of a visual spectacle in twentieth-century Korea. She is the author of Aesthetic Constructions of Korean Nationalism (Routledge, forthcoming). She was a postdoctoral research fellow at the Asia-Pacific Research Center in 2003-2005.
Philippines Conference Room
North Korea is a real country, with real people, says John Everard
"North Korea is a real
country with real people getting on with their lives," said John Everard,
former British ambassador to North Korea, to a full-house audience at a Korean Studies
Program (KSP) lunchtime seminar on October 8, 2010. In his introduction of
Everard, David Straub, KSP's associate director, noted the lack of reliable
information about North Korea. Official government information is limited and
everyday life is perhaps even less understood. Everard, who served in North
Korea from 2006-2008, offered a firsthand perspective of ordinary people living
inside North Korea, giving a very human dimension to a country often regarded
only as a closed military state.
The darker side of life in North Korea is poverty, which is more acute now than
in earlier decades. Everard stated that North Korea was ahead of South Korea
economically until the 1970s and that the universal healthcare system put in
place by Kim Il-sung was initially effective. The World Health Organization now
provides most medical care in North Korea. Agriculture, once mechanized, has
largely reverted to animal power and hunger, though not at famine level as it
was in the 1990s, is still a major issue.
Leisure and social time also play a part of life in North Korea. People in
Pyongyang frequent coffee shops and throughout the country neighbors gather for
lively games of chess. Everard explained that daily activities like talking
with family and friends are just as much a part of life in North Korea as they
are in other parts of the world.
A bigger difference in North Korean society is the degree to which piety to the
leading regime and service to the government is significantly integrated into
life. Newly married couples, for example, will wear badges bearing images of
Kim Il-sung pinned to their formal wedding clothes and lay flowers before a
statue of the deceased leader. More than such customs though, Everard noted,
North Korea's military service requirement has the biggest impact on people.
Not only is the duration of eight to ten years significantly longer than the required
one to two years of most countries, military life is also very strenuous.
Social attitudes in North Korea are changing, as are attitudes toward the
outside world. Employees from North Korea now work for South Korean companies
within the successful Kaesong Industrial Zone, which opened in 2004. Foreign
goods, such as clothing, have also made their way into North Korea. People,
suggested Everard, are beginning to modestly aspire to own more material
possessions, like bicycles, and to learn more about the customs and cultures of
other parts of the world.
Everard spoke about North Korea's relations with other countries. China has a
natural interest in the stability of North Korea-its neighbor to the
northeast-for its own welfare and it therefore supports it economically and
politically. Despite a large Russian Federation embassy in Pyongyang, relations
with Russia are not as strong as they were with the old Soviet Union, Everard
said. Although the United States is officially regarded as an aggressor and an
enemy, most people Everard met with did not express animosity toward Americans.
"There is an openness toward warm relations with Americans if political
relations improve," he said.
Everard described the curiosity expressed by North Koreans who asked him about
life in the United States-about everything ranging from music to social
conditions. Audience members-from the United States, China, Japan, South Korea,
and numerous other countries-asked him an equally broad range of questions,
demonstrating that perhaps there is an equal amount of curiosity and
willingness to connect both inside and outside of North Korea.
John Everard is KSP's 2010-2011 Pantech Fellow. The David Straub, generously funded by the Pantech Group of Korea, are intended to cultivate a diverse international community of scholars and professionals committed to and capable of grappling with challenges posed by developments in Korea.
Joon Nak Choi
Shorenstein APARC
Encina Hall
Stanford University
Stanford, CA 94305-6055
Joon Nak Choi is the 2015-2016 Koret Fellow in the Korea Program at Stanford University's Walter H. Shorenstein Asia-Pacific Research Center (Shorenstein APARC). A sociologist by training, Choi is an assistant professor at Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. His research and teaching areas include economic development, social networks, organizational theory, and global and transnational sociology, within the Korean context.
Choi, a Stanford graduate, has worked jointly with professor Gi-Wook Shin to analyze the transnational bridges linking Asia and the United States. The research project explores how economic development links to foreign skilled workers and diaspora communities.
Most recently, Choi coauthored Global Talent: Skilled Labor as Social Capital in Korea with Shin, who is also the director of the Korea Program. From 2010-11, Choi developed the manuscript while he was a William Perry postdoctoral fellow at Shorenstein APARC.
North Korea under Kim Jong-un: time for a paradigm shift
U.S. role crucial in Northeast Asian reconciliation
John Roos, U.S. Ambassador to Japan, conducted a historic visit in August 2010 to Peace Memorial Park in Hiroshima. What is the possibility of and the implications for a similar U.S. Presidential visit? Gi-Wook Shin, director of Shorenstein APARC and the Korean Studies Program, explores this question and suggests that the U.S. must play a role in the reconciliation of World War II memories in Northeast Asia.