All Shorenstein APARC News Commentary May 5, 2021

The Crisis After the Crisis: How Ladakh Will Shape India’s Competition with China

The border crisis in Ladakh may end in war or peace — or it may never end.
Indian army convoy carrying reinforcement and supplies.
Indian army convoy carrying reinforcement and supplies, drive towards Leh, on a highway bordering China, on September 2, 2020 in Gagangir, India. Yawar Nazir / Getty Images

This paper was originally published by The Lowy Institute.

In May 2020, China launched several near-simultaneous incursions across the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in Ladakh, into territory hitherto controlled by India. Both sides reinforced their positions with tens of thousands of troops, engaged in a deadly skirmish, and reportedly came close to war. An agreement to disengage troops was announced in February 2021, but implementation has been halting. Regardless of how disengagement progresses, the crisis poses significant challenges for India’s long-term strategic competition with China.

As a result of the Ladakh crisis, India faces a new strategic reality in which China is a clear and abiding adversary. For India, the political relationship is now defined by hostility and distrust, and the LAC will remain more heavily militarized and violence-prone. Given this new reality, India is likely to further defer military modernization and maritime expansion into the Indian Ocean. In the face of unremitting Chinese naval expansion, India risks losing significant political and military leverage in the Indian Ocean. At the same time, China appears to have escaped significant harm. Its better-resourced military could better absorb the material costs of the mobilization. It may have been more concerned by the prospect of an increasingly hostile India, but the disengagement agreement has limited even those modest political costs.

[Sign up for APARC's newsletters to receive the latest commentary and analysis from our experts] 

The central policy challenge for India is balancing the heightened Chinese military threat on the northern border with the rapidly growing Chinese military presence in the Indian Ocean. It can manage this challenge by focusing on military strategies of denial rather than punishment, focusing on imposing political rather than material costs on China, and accepting more risk at the LAC in exchange for long-term leverage in the Indian Ocean region. How India responds will shape not only its strategic competition with China, but also the interests of likeminded partners including Australia, which depend on an increasingly capable and active India.

 

read more

Small flags of North Korea and China for sale near the China-North Korea border
Commentary

China’s Dangerous Double Game in North Korea

Biden must force Beijing to cooperate fully with Washington or pivot to obvious obstruction writes FSI Center Fellow Oriana Skylar Mastro in her latest op-ed for Foreign Affairs.
Aircraft assigned to the Theodore Roosevelt Carrier Strike Group fly over the South China Sea
Commentary

How China is Bending the Rules in the South China Sea

Beijing’s misapplication of international law in the disputed waters is more complex than it seems on the surface.
Two destroyer navy ships sail alongside each other
Commentary

India Should Prioritize a Denial Strategy in the Indian Ocean

The stand-off with China in the Himalayas has raised a broader debate about India’s strategic outlook.